Rugby and American football are among the most physical team sports. We’re taking a look at the numbers to figure out which is the more demanding of the two.
As most athletes know, playing a team sport means you’re pretty competitive. And when we say competitive, we mean it in every sense of the word.
Listening to a rugbyman and an American footballer go at it is the perfect example.
There’s no denying that both rugby and American football are among the toughest team sports in the world. (Yes, Australian football, we see you glaring.)
But if you’ve ever heard athletes from both disciplines arguing over which of the two is more demanding, you realize that it’s a pretty close debate.
Or so it seems…
Thanks to technological advancements, we can now circumvent opinions and actually compare statistics from both sports. In this article, we’ll define three different categories and compare rugby players to American footballers to figure out once and for all which of the two is the more demanding sport.
A Brief History of Rugby
Modern rugby as we know it started in Warwickshire in 1823. According to the legendary anecdote, a young boy by the name of William Webb Ellis picked up a football in his hands and ran forward with it. Fast forward almost 200 years and rugby is among the most popular sports worldwide.
While there are many variants of rugby, for the purpose of this article, we will focus on the categories known as Rugby Union and Rugby League. The two are very similar, with a few key differentiators.
For instance, Union is played with 15 players on each team, while League teams consist of 13 aside. Rugby League is often considered the more physically gruelling and spectator-friendly of the two as it was designed to promote faster gameplay.
The Rise of American Football
American football is a relatively new sport; it was invented in the 19th century. Anyone that has even seen a game or simply held an American football can deduce that this sport was derived (at least partially) from rugby. The first college American football game was played in 1869. However, the basic rules of modern American football were not invented until the mid 1880s by Walter Camp, a renowned Yale University rugby player.
Today, American footballers wear about 10 kgs of protective gear. This includes shoulder pads, a helmet, and lower body protection. The team’s quarterback is the most important player as he is in charge of throwing (forward) passes to the receivers.
In rugby, you are only allowed to pass the ball backwards, and protection is usually not worn (some players wear lightweight shoulder pads though).
And if you think a scrum cap offers any protection (aside from a feeble attempt to prevent cauliflower ears), believe it when we say you’d be better off growing an afro like Colin Charvis!
Head to Head Comparison
American footballers are often cited as being the toughest athletes, but it’s time to let the numbers do the talking.
Below, we have collected information on three different categories in order to compare them head to heard and declare an ultimate winner.
Figuring out which athletes run fastest can be a bit tricky. While maximum speed is a good indicator, we should also keep in mind that American football players wear a hefty layer of padding.
The best way to compare the two is to take stats from the NFL training combine, where players carry out a series of timed drills without any padding. For comparison purposes, we will use the speed stats from Jarryd Hayne, Australian rugby league superstar that tried his luck in the NFL back in 2015.
The top speed recorded at the NFL combine for a 40-yard dash (36.6 meters) was 4.31 seconds in 2016. On the other hand, Hayne ran the same distance in 4.53 seconds during his 2015 stint with the 49ers, which is also extremely fast.
However, American footballers seem to have the upper hand in this category, with some players running at speeds of 22 mph while wearing their protective gear.
Winner: American Football
Both rugby and American football are known for big hits and jaw-dropping tackles, but which athletes endure the hardest hits? To get a better idea, we’ll go over some basic concepts.
You’ve probably already heard of g-force in both rugby and American football. This measurement can be described as a type of acceleration that causes the accelerating object to experience pressure acting in the opposite direction. The force is measured in units called gs. One g is equal to the force of gravity on Earth’s surface, which is 9.8 meters per second per second.
What you need to know is that gs represent the impact felt by an athlete. To put it in perspective, a high-speed roller coaster can exert anywhere between 3 and 6 gs on your body. But how does this compare to the force felt by these athletes?
There are many elements that impact the force of a tackle. Rugby players can experience hits with more than 10 gs of strength multiple times during a game. On the other hand, American footballers may experience an average tackle force of more than 25 gs, but their padding and helmet absorb most of the impact.
It’s clear that American Football players take more of a hit in terms of G force but it would be interesting to know how much the padding absorbs and to compare with Rugby. Overall, American Football takes this.
Winner: American Football
Total Tackles and Hits Per Game
While the destructive force of both rugby and American football tackles can cause some serious damage, we also want to look at the number of tackles in a game.
In order to compare them accurately, let’s take a look at the average number of tackles in an NFL game during the 2016 season. Jerrell Freeman from the Chicago Bears led the league with just over seven tackles per game.
Rugby players such as Robbie Henshaw can tackle 10 times or more in a game, which he did in Ireland’s thrilling victory over France in the first fixture of this year’s Six Nations. This gives rugby another point, especially if you consider the protective gear American footballers have.
Note: There are also more collisions in rugby such as rucks, mauls and scrums. This is also true for American Football as there are many blockers but overall there would be more tackles and hits per game across the board in Rugby due to the continuous play for 40 minutes each half and every player getting involved in some kind of tackle/hits/collisions.
When measuring toughness, it’s not all about the big hits and speed. One must look at how hard the game is to play and how much mental strength, stamina and endurance comes into play.
On average, rugby union players cover around 6 miles per game.
On average, American football players only run around 1 mile per game and they only actually played for an average of 11 minutes whilst rugby players play for a full 80 minutes. That’s a HUGE difference.
Rugby players run more, hit more and have to be mentally switched on for 69 more minutes than American Football players.
Rugby players don’t have the luxury of being able to stop the play each breakdown, they must get back up, get back in line, make that last-ditch tackle, cover that kick over the top etc.
It’s a whole different game when you have to combine strength, speed, power and stamina. This is why Rugby wins this section by far.
Picture this scenario (it happens frequently)
It’s the last 5 minutes and the opposition have just thumbed a monster kick downfield, it’s a footrace. The ball lands in your 22 and the opposition win it.
You make that last-ditch tackle and get back on your feet to try and win the ball only to the smashed back by the opposition f0wards clearing the ruck, they play the ball fast.
You HAVE to get up and get in line only to be lined up with their 120kg battering ram of a prop, another big hit goes in.
You’re now on your try line defending attack after attack. You’ve had no chance for a breather or to think. Your body is on the line until the final whistle.
Scenarios like the above happen often in Rugby, especially at the top international games. Teams defending until the death on their try-line and it makes for great entertainment. With American Football players only playing on average 11 minutes of total game time, this makes it an easy win for Rugby.
Declaring a Winner
It’s a 2/2 draw but a winner must be picked. Due to the Stamina and continuous play of Rugby, we’ll have to go with Rugby being the tougher sport overall.
So next time you’re involved in such a discussion, remember that rugby trumps American football overall. They can have the biggest hits and fastest players but when it comes down to it, Rugby is the toughest sport in the World.
There’s no doubt that NFL players are elite athletes but the stop-start nature of the game vs the 80 minutes of intensity in rugby is not comparable, even if they do on paper put in bigger hits in the games.